Comments on: Monash Uni: closed island? /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/ Coverage of news, issues and events occurring in virtual worlds or those who create those worlds Sat, 01 Jan 2011 03:53:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.4 By: Angsty Rossini /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-18019 Angsty Rossini Fri, 23 Nov 2007 05:04:33 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-18019 I am one of those people who has a clear demarcation between my RL identity and my SL avatar. There is no cross-over between the 2, nor would I ever want there to be. No, I don't have anything to hide, or be afraid of, nor do I slink around dong nefarious things in SL. Taking on a different persona in SL gives me the opportunity to explore who I am, play out roles and scenarios that I would be too inhibited or introverted to replicate in RL (no, NOT sex!) This is a personal and private journey for me and my avatar and frankly, I would consider it a breach of my privacy to have my virtual name linked to my real life name - on par with you asking me for my bank PIN details. I understand where Debbie was coming from in being bemused that someone took issue at a request to link RL and SL identities, but you also need to understand and accept that the other side of this argument is just as valid. Angsty I am one of those people who has a clear demarcation between my RL identity and my SL avatar. There is no cross-over between the 2, nor would I ever want there to be.

No, I don’t have anything to hide, or be afraid of, nor do I slink around dong nefarious things in SL.

Taking on a different persona in SL gives me the opportunity to explore who I am, play out roles and scenarios that I would be too inhibited or introverted to replicate in RL (no, NOT sex!)

This is a personal and private journey for me and my avatar and frankly, I would consider it a breach of my privacy to have my virtual name linked to my real life name – on par with you asking me for my bank PIN details.

I understand where Debbie was coming from in being bemused that someone took issue at a request to link RL and SL identities, but you also need to understand and accept that the other side of this argument is just as valid.

Angsty

]]>
By: Angsty Rossini /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135859 Angsty Rossini Fri, 23 Nov 2007 05:04:33 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135859 I am one of those people who has a clear demarcation between my RL identity and my SL avatar. There is no cross-over between the 2, nor would I ever want there to be. <br><br>No, I don't have anything to hide, or be afraid of, nor do I slink around dong nefarious things in SL. <br><br>Taking on a different persona in SL gives me the opportunity to explore who I am, play out roles and scenarios that I would be too inhibited or introverted to replicate in RL (no, NOT sex!) <br><br>This is a personal and private journey for me and my avatar and frankly, I would consider it a breach of my privacy to have my virtual name linked to my real life name - on par with you asking me for my bank PIN details.<br><br>I understand where Debbie was coming from in being bemused that someone took issue at a request to link RL and SL identities, but you also need to understand and accept that the other side of this argument is just as valid.<br><br>Angsty I am one of those people who has a clear demarcation between my RL identity and my SL avatar. There is no cross-over between the 2, nor would I ever want there to be.

No, I don’t have anything to hide, or be afraid of, nor do I slink around dong nefarious things in SL.

Taking on a different persona in SL gives me the opportunity to explore who I am, play out roles and scenarios that I would be too inhibited or introverted to replicate in RL (no, NOT sex!)

This is a personal and private journey for me and my avatar and frankly, I would consider it a breach of my privacy to have my virtual name linked to my real life name – on par with you asking me for my bank PIN details.

I understand where Debbie was coming from in being bemused that someone took issue at a request to link RL and SL identities, but you also need to understand and accept that the other side of this argument is just as valid.

Angsty

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-17441 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 13:31:08 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-17441 No problem Anon but thanks for the apology anyway. I look forward to catching up inworld so you can show me around your island(s). Cheers! Deb No problem Anon but thanks for the apology anyway. I look forward to catching up inworld so you can show me around your island(s).

Cheers!
Deb

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135858 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 13:31:08 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135858 No problem Anon but thanks for the apology anyway. I look forward to catching up inworld so you can show me around your island(s). <br><br>Cheers!<br>Deb No problem Anon but thanks for the apology anyway. I look forward to catching up inworld so you can show me around your island(s).

Cheers!
Deb

]]>
By: Anon /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-17409 Anon Sun, 18 Nov 2007 07:27:43 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-17409 Hi Deb I did have some concerns, but I do apologize if they came over too strong. I felt strongly about this, but they could have been shrunk into a single sentence, as a passing remark, or discussed with you privately. I know you worked very hard at organizing this conference. Sometimes it's easy to write about concerns and then wish they could be softened after. So again, apologies if they came across as an over-reaction. Hi Deb

I did have some concerns, but I do apologize if they came over too strong. I felt strongly about this, but they could have been shrunk into a single sentence, as a passing remark, or discussed with you privately.

I know you worked very hard at organizing this conference. Sometimes it’s easy to write about concerns and then wish they could be softened after. So again, apologies if they came across as an over-reaction.

]]>
By: Anon /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135857 Anon Sun, 18 Nov 2007 07:27:43 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135857 Hi Deb<br><br>I did have some concerns, but I do apologize if they came over too strong. I felt strongly about this, but they could have been shrunk into a single sentence, as a passing remark, or discussed with you privately. <br><br>I know you worked very hard at organizing this conference. Sometimes it's easy to write about concerns and then wish they could be softened after. So again, apologies if they came across as an over-reaction. Hi Deb

I did have some concerns, but I do apologize if they came over too strong. I felt strongly about this, but they could have been shrunk into a single sentence, as a passing remark, or discussed with you privately.

I know you worked very hard at organizing this conference. Sometimes it’s easy to write about concerns and then wish they could be softened after. So again, apologies if they came across as an over-reaction.

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-17375 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:45:20 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-17375 p.s Keep up the good work. I rely on your blog as one of my main sources of OZ SL info! Cheers again Deb p.s Keep up the good work. I rely on your blog as one of my main sources of OZ SL info!

Cheers again
Deb

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135856 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:45:20 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135856 p.s Keep up the good work. I rely on your blog as one of my main sources of OZ SL info!<br><br>Cheers again<br>Deb p.s Keep up the good work. I rely on your blog as one of my main sources of OZ SL info!

Cheers again
Deb

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-17374 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:41:29 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-17374 No worries Lowell but maybe ask us next time - you know where we live! And again, I have no issue with Anons comments other than they were factually incorrect and highly exaggerated. Cheers Deb No worries Lowell but maybe ask us next time – you know where we live!

And again, I have no issue with Anons comments other than they were factually incorrect and highly exaggerated.

Cheers
Deb

]]>
By: Seeker Esparza /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135855 Seeker Esparza Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:41:29 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135855 No worries Lowell but maybe ask us next time - you know where we live!<br><br>And again, I have no issue with Anons comments other than they were factually incorrect and highly exaggerated.<br><br>Cheers<br>Deb No worries Lowell but maybe ask us next time – you know where we live!

And again, I have no issue with Anons comments other than they were factually incorrect and highly exaggerated.

Cheers
Deb

]]>
By: Lowell Cremorne /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-17373 Lowell Cremorne Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:26:57 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-17373 Hi Debbie, Thanks for your considered response. When I first read the article I was surprised at the comment and initial reaction was 'surely that's out of context' but I thought the question was well worth asking anyway. ;) I look forward to seeing the final build. As far as Anon, I have no idea who he/she is but being an open forum, I welcome the discussion. The RL/SL issue is an ongoing one that creates a lot of debate. Also, having not being there I didn't see the comment as being over the top at all, just a concern expressed. Lowell Hi Debbie,

Thanks for your considered response. When I first read the article I was surprised at the comment and initial reaction was ‘surely that’s out of context’ but I thought the question was well worth asking anyway. ;)

I look forward to seeing the final build. As far as Anon, I have no idea who he/she is but being an open forum, I welcome the discussion. The RL/SL issue is an ongoing one that creates a lot of debate. Also, having not being there I didn’t see the comment as being over the top at all, just a concern expressed.

Lowell

]]>
By: Lowell Cremorne /2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/comment-page-1/#comment-135854 Lowell Cremorne Sun, 18 Nov 2007 01:26:57 +0000 http://www.sloz.info/2007/11/16/monash-uni-closed-island/#comment-135854 Hi Debbie,<br><br>Thanks for your considered response. When I first read the article I was surprised at the comment and initial reaction was 'surely that's out of context' but I thought the question was well worth asking anyway. ;)<br><br>I look forward to seeing the final build. As far as Anon, I have no idea who he/she is but being an open forum, I welcome the discussion. The RL/SL issue is an ongoing one that creates a lot of debate. Also, having not being there I didn't see the comment as being over the top at all, just a concern expressed.<br><br>Lowell Hi Debbie,

Thanks for your considered response. When I first read the article I was surprised at the comment and initial reaction was ‘surely that’s out of context’ but I thought the question was well worth asking anyway. ;)

I look forward to seeing the final build. As far as Anon, I have no idea who he/she is but being an open forum, I welcome the discussion. The RL/SL issue is an ongoing one that creates a lot of debate. Also, having not being there I didn’t see the comment as being over the top at all, just a concern expressed.

Lowell

]]>